Book Clubs are Talking About...

« January 2008 | Main | March 2008 »

February 2008

February 28, 2008

My Book Group Met Last Week to Discuss Ian McEwan's Saturday

And I wasn't there! Alas, I was on vacation last week, so missed my book group meeting. I was very disappointed, as I really loved Saturday and was looking forward to talking about it. But lucikly we have a report from Ellen (thank you Ellen!) who was that night's hostess and is also the one who keeps us all organized and scheduled (she also keeps the master list of books we've discussed, without which that section on the bottom right of this blog would be very empty). In any event, onto her report.

Given that it was a vacation week, we had a small group of 7 present, and believe it or not, 1 conversation! Group dynamics are fascinating. Only 3 of us had read the book and luckily one of them was JH, who was able to illuminate some of the book themes in a literary fashion. I thought her best insight was when she compared the power struggle between Henry (the rich and powerful) and Baxter (the powerless) to that of the US and the terrorists of 9/11. Although no one loved the book, we were all glad that we had read it.

In terms of choosing the next book, the only real contenders (from the below list) were Family Matters and Plain Truth by Jodi Picoult. Family Matters won by a vote, probably because no one had read a book by Rohinton Mistry. The other books voted on were:
Family_mattersCavedweller by Dorothy Allison
The Girls' Guide to Hunting & Fishing by Melissa Bank
The Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield

Here are resources for Family Matters: the reading group guide, about the author, excerpt, praise

Book Club Girl's Online Radio Debut!

Listen to Book Club Girl on internet talk radio Check out my first online radio show here, in which I host Jamie Saul, author of Light of Day, as he talks to a book group in New York City about his book. I'd love to hear what you think of the show!

February 26, 2008

How to Make Your Book Club More Effective a Guest Blog Series from Book Club Classics - Part 3

Herewith part 3 of the guest blog series "How to Make Your Book Club More Effective" from Kristen, the founder of Book Club Classics, a site that provides book club kits fir specific works of classic literature. This time her topic is "How to Hear Every Voice." Read part one of the series here and part two here.

Image001_2Now that we've addressed the benefits of embracing a theme and choosing appropriate works, it's time to tackle the reason we join book clubs in the first place: discussion. As an introvert, I am intimately aware of how I used to allow others to voice their opinions while keeping my own quiet. My "excuse" always was..."I already know what I think -- I want to hear others' ideas and thoughts."

While this is true on a certain level, I now realize that every member of a book club or classroom has a responsibility to participate and add to the discussion. Each and every individual's voice is distinct and important and no one should be able to take a back seat -- or dominate -- any discussion.

The question is...How do we make this desire a reality? Too often, one or two voices are too present and drown out those who are too absent, turning what should be a lively discussion into a tiresome diatribe.

A good friend of mine, with many years experience in the classroom, provided a wonderful solution to this all too common problem. She believes that a book club should start with a concrete, yet subjective question and ask every member to voice his/her opinion before starting the discussion. She has found that hearing every voice right from the start encourages the quieter members to speak out throughout the discussion and reminds the more vociferous members not to "hold court."

The warm-up question should NOT be: "So, did you like the book?" This question tends to lead to a subjective discussion -- especially if one member did not care for the novel, the tenor can turn negative very quickly, and those who did enjoy aspects of the work may silence their dissenting opinion. (More on this common mistake in part 5).

A better question to begin with might be: Which character did you connect to the most (or least) and why? Another might be: Which part of the story was the most engaging? Or: What first impression turned out to be incorrect? Notice that all of these questions are subjective in that there really isn't one right answer and the member must disclose something about themselves without getting too personal. Even quiet members will be encouraged to voice an opinion and hopefully then engage in the ensuing discussion.

February 25, 2008

Talk with Paulo Coelho on GoodReads and Read His New Book Online for Free!

PauloCheck out GoodReads for an exclusive interview with Paulo Coelho, author of The Alchemist and the new The Witch of Portobello, about his life, his writing and his new avant garde filmmaking contest, The Experimental Witch. Witch_2

In addition to the interview, you can ask Coelho questions directly in the Q&A Group with Paulo Coelho from now until this Friday, February 29th.

And, for a limited time, you can read The Witch of Portobello online for free!

Diane Rehm's New Reader's Review Book is Three Cups of Tea

Three_cupsI had the pleasure of hearing a lot of Diane Rehm while on vacation last week -- her shows and her interviews are so interesting and I gained such an understanding of what is happening in Cuba listening to one show in particular. If you haven't listened to her, I encourage you to do so. After discussing The Prince on her show last week in her Readers' Review book club style discussion, she has announced her pick for March -- the bestseller Three Cups of Tea. Tea follows the adventures of real-life Indiana Jones Greg Mortenson, who, after a failed attempt to summit the K2, embarks on a humanitarian campaign to build schools for boys and girls in Pakistan, literally in the Taliban's backyard. You can read an excerpt here, check out the reading guide here, and tune in to the discussion on March 19th.

February 23, 2008

How to Pick a Book Club

BCG Reader Christi -- in a comment to the "How Does Your Book Group Pick New Members" post below -- sent a link to an article she wrote on how to choose a book club to join. It's a great piece, and I wanted to make sure everyone had a chance to read it, not just you dutiful readers of comments, so check it out here.

February 21, 2008

Laurie Viera Rigler on Masterpiece's Pride & Prejudice

Colin_firthI love Laurie's take on what I call the "Colin Firth Pride & Prejudice" (sorry Jennifer Ehle). It definitely is my standard against which all P&P adaptations are judged, though I will say I found the Keira Knightley movie wonderful. But given that that was a 2-hour adapation as opposed to this longer form, miniseries treatment, I do think they are apples and oranges and one can love each of them without any conflict. I still remember studying P&P religiously for my senior year English major "orals" exam where I was grilled by three professors about three works of my choosing. Choosing Austen made studying all the easier. Part 3 airs on Sunday, February 24th opposite the Oscars, so some tivo'ing may be required.

February 19, 2008

"How to Make Your Book Club More Effective" A Guest Blog Series from Book Club Classics - Part 2

Herewith part two of the guest blog series "How To Make Your Book Club More Effective," from Kristen, the creator of Book Club Classics, a site that provides book club kits for specific works of classic literature. With Target now promoting classic literature, there's never been a better time to check out her site. Read part one of her series here.

Bookstack So, ever finish a book club meeting and think...We really didn't discuss the book that  much? There could be many reasons for this, but I think the first to consider is that nature of the work chosen.

Ask yourself, what was the focus of the book:  Characters?  Theme?  Plot?  If your club chose a book whose strength was its plot, your group may have had a hard time getting past “Did you like it?”

My book club recently read and (sort of) discussed Basket Case by Carl Hiassen.  I hate to admit this, but I (guiltily) did not finish this one.  This is very unusual for me, but it did provide a certain distance from the discussion that allowed me to examine the dynamics rather than the content of what was said.  The first half of Basket Case was funny — that was its strength, in my opinion – but it really didn’t encourage discussion.

(Personally, I thought the main character was a bit static and stereotypical — but I have a hard time believing many of the “heroes” of popular male fiction anyway.  A little too “jaded, but not really”…  “sexually adventurous, but still secretly yearning for a companion” etc…). 

I noticed after everyone had voiced their opinions on whether or not they enjoyed the book (Men = yes, Women = not so much), the discussion stymied and eventually dissolved into socializing. 

When a novel’s focus is plot-based, it can be difficult to get beyond -- “Remember when this happened?”  “Wasn’t it funny when…?” -- to more interesting questions of theme or the psychology of the characters.

The best books for discussion confront themes and conflicts that are more universal and also more challenging. 

For example, in A Thousand Splendid Suns, very popular book club book, a central irony in the story is that ousting the Soviet occupation from Afghanistan resulted in much worse oppression for the women, who had experienced many freedoms under the communist philosophy.  So, a book club could discuss the U.S.’s involvement in the Cold War and whether routing communism was really for the best for that country.  Is it better for a group of people to have the freedom to rule independently, even if half the population subsequently loses their independence?  There are many answers to that complex question…

If your club has decided on a theme, this can also guide your choice of what to read and then what to discuss (like how well the specific theme is portrayed in each work, etc.). 

The ability to engender great discussion is why I love the classics for book clubs, too — there are many very good reasons why a classic endures, beyond a mastery of the language.  The challenge of confronting the syntax and diction of a previous time is rewarded by the unlocking of the secrets within, and universal themes are universally interesting!  (And fodder for great discussion, usually, too).  Stay tuned to learn how to get every member’s voice heard in every discussion… Coming next week!

February 17, 2008

Target's New Book Club Pick is the Classic A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

Tree"The world was hers for the reading."

Target's new book club pick is Betty Smith's classic coming-of-age novel A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. This marks the first time that Target has chosen a classic for their book club--where their focus has been primarily on contemporary literature. It's exciting that they've chosen such a timeless work, one that will be re-introduced to many who read it growing up, and newly introduced to their many shoppers. Read an excerpt here, and here is the reading group guide.

February 15, 2008

Interview with Book Club Favorite Jill Davis Plus a Chance to Win a Trip to NYC!

JillJill Davis's first novel, Girl's Poker Night, burst on the scene in 2002 and became a must read for women everywhere. I still remember reading it, loving it, and passing it along to my friends. Jill's new novel, Ask Again Later, is just out in paperback and in it she tells the story of Emily, a woman who has always lived with one foot out the door. When her mother announces that she has cancer, Emily glady leaves her career, her boyfriend and her life to be by her mother's side. But once she's back in her childhood home, she realizes that everything holding her back in her life may have its roots right there...

I had the opportunity to interview Jill about her books and writing this week:

BCG: You started your writing career writing comedy (for David Letterman). When you began writing your first book, Girls' Poker Night, can you describe the transition from writing late-night comedy to writing a full length novel? How much of your own life at time found its way into the book?

JD: I started writing for a newspaper while I was still in college. I wrote a weekly humor column. Later, after college, I was a feature and news writer as well as a humor columnist. Many of the things I was doing in my columns translated well to the sorts of things Dave was doing on his show. At the time he was taking the camera out on the street a lot. So I would write an idea, write some jokes in advance of the shoot and then also write on location. Of course, the funniest things were always things Dave came up with on the spot just like he does during his show with guests. But the writing on location was exactly like writing on a deadline for newspapers. In both newspaper and television I had a daily deadline which is excellent training. The major difference is that when you write for television you're really trying to write as terse and as funny of a joke as possible and in someone else's voice; in newspapers I generally had a specific amount of space I was filling and the writing didn't have to be as short as on TV and my column was written in the first person. I started to write short stories while I was still writing for Dave, I suppose after a few years of writing in a man's voice I was really ready to write in my own again. Writing short stories was pure joy for me. I think that experience solidified my idea of writing a novel. It was something I'd always wanted to do, and planned to do. I did get side- tracked and wrote a few screenplays and pilots for sit-coms along the way. The greatest transition was to my lifestlye. I was used to working 12 hours a day, and someone else deciding for the most part what material would be used and what would be discarded. When I went to work writing my first novel, I got to decide what to keep and what to throw away. As far as my own life finding it's way into my books, it's of course unavoidable. While the stories and the characters are fictious, the books are psychologically autobiographical in many ways.

BCG: Were you prepared for the response that GPN generated?

JD: No, I don't think I was. Girls' Poker Night was the first book I'd ever written and I really had no idea what to anticipate. I was so happy just to see it in a bookstore, on a shelf, that I'm not sure how much I thought about whether or not anyone would buy the book. Of course, at some point it does hit when you are standing in a bookstore, that, goodness there sure are a lot of books here - how on earth on people going to find it? Read it? It was very much a word-of-mouth book at first. The best part about a book that does well, of course, is that it allows you to write another one.

BCG: What, if anything, in your life changed between the writing of Girls' Poker Night and your newest novel Ask Again Later and how did it inform the level at which you were writing, and the themes you addressed?

The most significant experience of my life happened - I became a mother. I have a daughter who will be 5 next week. She was born the same week that the paperback of Girls' Poker Night was released. At some point that week I was breast-feeding and doing a radio interview at the same time and it struck me that it was probably time to take a little time off. I'm all for multi-tasking, don't get me wrong, but I knew I couldn't rush through things and more importantly I didn't want to. I have a tendency to throw myself into things all the way, and so then I think I got very interested in any and every new mom class that could be offered. I'm not kidding, I even went to a baby massage class. It's not like babies get lower back pain. Looking back I think it's hilarious, but I was probably sort of serious about it at the time! In terms of theme, both books deal with risk taking, loss, second chances and growing up. But in Ask Again Later I spend more time on the Mother/Daughter relationship but it is a chapter called BABY that is really the most autobiographical in terms of how I felt when my daughter was born, when I saw her for the first time.

BCG: You’ve talked to a lot of book groups, what’s been the most interesting and unexpected thing you’ve heard from them when discussing Ask Again Later?

JD: They are all interesting and always for different reasons. I love hearing how people respond to both books. When you write a novel, at least in my case, I write in total isolation and I don't discuss what I'm writing with anyone. It's a real immersion, and also in a way protective. I love when people start to defend certain characters' behavior, because to me that means the characters came to life for the reader. It's also amazing to hear people's very personal stories about having survived cancer - and you might think this would be very sad, but what's remarkable to me is the very positive way that many people deal with scary news. So many people say they are in the best shape of their lives because they've completely changed their old habits and they are more likely to train for a marathon, or travel, because their priorities are reordered. A lot of people mention the gold fish chapter - which is a chapter I really love.

BCG: What kinds of books do you like to read, and what are you reading now? I normally read fiction, but at the moment I'm reading two books. One is The Omnivore's Dilemma, a friend told me I had to read it because I will never look at corn - and eating it - the same way again. And I hadn't considered that I might need to rethink my position on corn, in fact I wasn't even sure I had a position on corn, so it intrigued me.  I'm also reading The Act of Creation by Arthur Koestler. That one might be out of print - I say that because it has that old book smell when you open it and there's a receipt from a bookseller that's good at hunting things down. Anyway, my husband bought it for me as a gift. It's about - well, the title kind of says it now, doesn't it? - it's about the thinking process and creativity, and how connections that are made, that haven't been made before, and how this leads to humor, scientific discovery, general advances.

BCG: Thank you so much Jill (and note, the Act of Creation is still in print, you can find it at the link above, sounds like a fascinating read).

Jill loves calling in to reading groups, if you're interested in inviting her to talk to yours, click here, you can browse inside the book here, and you'll find the reading group guide here.

And that's not all -- in honor of the paperback publication of Ask Again Later, you can enter the Ask Again Later Sweepstakes to win a trip to New York City and a $1,000 American Express Gift Card! Enter here!

February 13, 2008

Love Means Never Having to Say You're Out of Books to Recommend

Love_storyHappy Valentine's Day! In honor of this romantic day, why not revisit a classic of the genre -- Erich Segal's Love Story, which was also made of course, into the classic tearjerker starring Ali McGraw and Ryan O'Neal. I'm sure you've watched the movie at least once in the last few years, but have you re-read the book? Curl up with it (and a box of tissues) over the upcoming long weekend. Browse inside the book here, and check out the reading group guide here.

February 12, 2008

How Does Your Book Group Add New Members?

Reading_groupSomeone emailed me this question today, wondering how my book group decides to add new members, how they are "added" and what we do if that new person doesn't necessarily fit in. Sounds like in her group there's been some disagreement over some of the people who've recently joined, and they're not sure how to handle it. In addition, she lives in a small community where everyone knows each other, so a "book group breakup" can be difficult to handle. I'd love to know how others have dealt with this situation. In my own group people come who are friends with a current member, and so far, it's all worked out well. Does anyone's group have a trial period during which a person has to prove themself? Anyone have to disinvite someone from their group? Please share your stories in the comments section. I'll send a copy of The Reading Group by Elizabeth Noble (appropriately enough) to the first 20 people who reply!

Diane Rehm Discusses Machiavelli's The Prince

PrincePerhaps to help us better understand those currently running for president, Diane Rehm invites readers to join her next Wednesday, February 20th, to discuss Machiavelli's The Prince -- the ultimate book on power politics.

February 11, 2008

I Can't Resist this Complete Jane Austen Promo

February 10, 2008

"How to Make Your Book Club More Effective" A Guest Blog Series from Book Club Classics

Introducing a new series on Book Club Girl! Kristen, the creator of Book Club Classics, a site that provides book club kits for specific works of classic literature will offer her insight with the five-part series entitled "How To Make Your Book Club More Effective." Here is her first post -- look for one a week for the next four weeks. And check out her site, there are some wonderful resources there.

671339_flipping_pages_2Through the years, I have been blessed to be a member of a number of book clubs and, as the creator of BookClubClassics, I spend a lot of time considering why some book clubs are more satistfying than others. Most would agree that the common goals of most book clubs are to share what is usually a solitary experience -- reading -- and to learn more about themselves and each other through their interactions with literature. However, sometimes the literature gets deemphasized to the point of frustration and the original intent of the members is lost.

One of my goals when I create a custom kit for a book club is to facilitate an experience where the members engage with a work of literatre on a deeper level, and this largely depends on the existing tenor of the group. So, when a member first requests a custom book club kit, I send a questionnaire with questions like: What brought your group together? What is the best and worst book, discussion-wise, that your club has tackled? How much time is spent on the book vs. socializing? What is the nature of the dynamics of your group?

The last question can be the hardest to answer... Groups of people who meet with any regularity tend to develop an identity composed of, but still separate from, the sum of their parts! So how can your group bcome an even more effective book club?

Things_that_matter I think one key is to have a defined purpose or mission as a community of readers. For example: choosing to read the classics! Or choosing to read works that no one in the group has read before. Or choosing favorites the members have read before. Or political non-fiction.. chick lit...hopeful romances...etc. Recently a book club ordered a series of custom kits based on Edward Mendelson's The Things that Matter: What Seven Classic Novels Have to Say About the Stages of Life. The seven novels are: Frankenstein, Jane Eyre, Wuthering Heights, Middlemarch, Mrs. Dalloway, To the Lighthouse, and Between the Acts. According to the answers from their questionnaire, this book club is very effective and satisfying to its members. Every reader finishes each work prior to the book club and discussion largely remains focused on the chosen work.

Agreeing upon a theme seems to result in a more successful and fulfilling book club. The nature of the theme really isn't important, so long as the group agrees upon it. Personally, I like to be challenged with works outside of my usual milieu, and I'll read just about anything that is well-written or interesting or ground-breaking. As a former writing teacher, content (including plot) is less important to my enjoymnt than the quality of the actual writing. However, I have discovered that when someone holds a book near and dear, "poor writing" becomes insignificant. People just don't want to believe that they could love a book that was poorly written or insignificant with regard to the world of literature.

So I suggest agreeing upon a theme to provide focus and to avoid so many common complaints of book clubs: drifting conversations, avoiding selections, condescending questions of "merit." I would love to hear what "themes" or missions other book clubs have. And if you need inspiration, check out my upcoming Instant Classics series on Pulitzer Prize winners!

February 08, 2008

Fill Out the Reading Group Choices Survey for a Chance to Win $75!

ReadingGroupChoices is conducting their annual survey of book groups and want to hear from you! What books nurtured your best book group discussions in 2007? Share your favorites with other reading groups -- the results make for wonderful book lists to cull from in the coming year! Fill out the survey now and you'll be entered into a drawing to win $75 towards your next book group get together!

Introducing Book Club Girl Gal!

Perhaps I just miss paper dolls, but I think it's more than that. I'm truly obsessed with the site DesignHerGals.com, which marries my love for dolls with my love for stationery. Check it out, here's the Gal I designed based on me! You can choose hair color, outfit, accessories and more and then print your gal on notecards, stationery, recipe cards, mugs and other fun calling card items. And the best part? A portion of the proceeds go to the Gal to Gal Foundation dedicated to stage IV breast cancer patients. I'll be installing Book Club Girl Gal permanently on the site soon, just wanted to introduce her here first. Click on her to visit the site!

February 06, 2008

Pennie's Pick at Costco is Adam Braver's Mr. Lincoln's Wars

Mr_lincolns_warsThose of you who are Costco shoppers should know about Pennie Clark Ianniciello -- the Costco book buyer with excellent taste. Each month she presents "Pennie's Pick" in the Costco Connection magazine that is sent to members' homes and this month, in honor of President's Day coming up, her pick is the unique linked short story collection, Mr. Lincoln's Wars, by Adam Braver. My issue just arrived today and in it Pennie talks about her lifelong fascination with Lincoln and her delight upon finding Braver's book, which "imagines Lincoln in numerous settings and through the eyes of a variety of people, including a friend, his wife, a young Union soldier and even John Wilkes Booth. Copies of Mr. Lincoln's Wars are on sale at most Costco locations now, and for a limited time, you can enter to win one of 50 signed copies by emailing giveaway AT costco dot com with the subject line "Adam Braver."
Here's the reading group guide and an essay by Braver on writing the book
Visit Adam Braver's website
Browse Inside the book

Jane, Jane, Jane -- Guest Post by Laurie Viera Rigler!

Poster_mansfieldpark_playShe confesses she's a Jane Austen Addict, and I confess that I am behind in my Sunday night Jane viewing, what with work, children, and primary returns to take care of. So thank goodness we have Laurie Viera Rigler's wonderful take on Austen that she's writing for About.com's Classic lit blog. Here she is on Mansfield Park, the novel, in anticipation of the show, with a nice focus placed on talking about this most controversial of Miss Austen's works in a book club.

February 05, 2008

Join the Post-Birthday World Online Book Group Discussion

Post Over at the great book blog, Everyday I Write the Book! Sign up (at that site) now and you'll receive an advance copy of the paperback edition (on sale 2/26) that you can read in preparation for the book club discussion on the blog on Thursday, March 6th. I know some of you are already receiving advance copies from the promotion we ran in December so I hope you consider participating! Author Lionel Shriver will even answer a select number of questions from readers. You can browse inside a few pages of the book here, read my first post about the book here, and get all the info you need about the discussion at EDIWTB here.

February 04, 2008

Enter to Win a Tudors Prize Pack!

Tudors_2Here's a very enticing contest -- enter to win this Tudors prize pack including season one of the Showtime series on DVD, the novelization of season one, the companion book to the show, plus The Other Boleyn Girl by Philippa Gregory! Season two of the Tudors starts this spring on Showtime and the film adaptation of The Other Boleyn Girl opens on 2/29!

February 03, 2008

Super Duper Tuesday Prep

UndecidedI will now divert slightly into politics, but I'm still keeping it connected to books. If you are one of the estimated 7 million Americans who are undecided on who you will vote for, and you live in one of the more than 20 states who will vote in two days in the closest we'll ever come to a national primary, you can now read all of political analyst Mark Halperin's The Undecided Voter's Guide to the Next President, online and FOR FREE! In his excellent guide, Time magazine and ABC News analyst Halperin provides details on all the candidates, including where they come from, what they believe in, and what the White House could look like under their potential presidency plus some fun personal facts. It's essential reading before you enter the voting booth, so you can vote for who you believe will make the best president, not the best candidate. Read the book online free until February 11th.

February 02, 2008

Barnes & Noble Announces Discover Great New Writers Finalists

Bnlogo Barnes & Noble announced the finalists for its 2007 Discover Great New Writers Awards today. Winners in the fiction and nonfiction categories, who will each receive $10,000 and a year of promotion at the stores, will be announced on February 27th, following a reading by all six finalists at Barnes & Noble's Lincoln Triangle store in New York. The award honors what B&N deems the best work featured in the previous year's Discover Great New Writer's Program and if you're unfamiliar with this program, look for it in your local B&N, they pick some great books.
Here are this year's finalists:
Let_the_northernFICTION
Matthew Eck, The Farther Shore
Joshua Ferris, Then We Came to the End (reading group guide)
Vendela Vida, Let the Northern Lights Erase Your Name


SoldierNON FICTION
Kate Braestrup, Here If You Need Me: A True Story (reading group guide)
Elizabeth D. Samet, Soldier's Heart: Reading Literature Through Peace and War at West Point (reading group guide)
Yaroslav Trofimov, The Siege of Mecca: The Forgotten Uprising in Islam's Holiest Shrine and the Birth of Al Queda

Subscribe

MY RADIO SHOW

  • Listen to Book Club Girl on internet talk radio

Check it Out!

Who is Book Club Girl?

  • Book Club Girl is: a member of two book clubs currently -- one very official and one very ad-hoc -- an avid reader who spent most of her childhood immersed in a book, an English major who considered library school until she realized it was all about computers, so turned to publishing, where she now works (but she vows to talk about books from all over and not to simply flog those from her own house). She was single, lived in the city, met a man, moved to the 'burbs, and is now a wife, a stepmother, a mother, and in her spare time, a fledgling blogger dedicated to sharing great books, news and tips with book club girls everywhere.

Contact

  • bookclubgirl AT gmail DOT com

Book Club Girl's Book Club Is Reading

Book Club Girl's Book Club Has Read